Is this me (I)?

A reader writes:

I’m a huge fan, and I’ve always wanted to write in with thoughtful responses to your work. But, alas, my question is trivial today. Perhaps in time I’ll share what an impact several of your works have had on me.
Is this picture from the Onion you? I notice striking similarities in the eyes and general facial structure. And with the caption, I thought it was a perfect fit.
http://www.theonion.com/articles/area-christian-forgives-you,9305/

Here’s the Onion photo:

Here’s a picture of me from an album cover of that era:

As an Onion fan, all I can say is let the people decide.